Sunday, July 19, 2015

DCCOD Problems with false detection

From Bruce Chubb 07/19/2015

Bob Jacobsen in his response and recommendation is exactly correct. I am certain that the problem you are experiencing is a result of incorrect block wiring and/or incorrect rail gap placement creating what I refer to as "sneak circuits".  That is, there are multiple paths, connected through multiple detectors, for the current flowing to detected track sections.

All it takes is one feeder drop from the detected rail of a given track section(say detected section A) to be connected to a wrong detector (say detector B) while all the other drops are connected to the correct detector (say detector A) . With this you have a low resistance path from detected section A  to the correct detector A and you have a slightly higher resistance from detected section A to detector B.

Place your hand across the track at Section A and only the correct Detector A shows detection as it should. This is because the great majority of the feeble current generated through your hand into track section A goes through the lowest resistance path and not enough of the current goes through the slightly higher resistance path through Detector B for detector B to show occupied. Thus placing your hand across blocks all seems to be working fine.

Now, place a locomotive in Section A. Being a much lower resistance, a much heavier current flows in Section A. It divides, just like in the previous case, but now the portion flowing through Detector B is sufficient so that  Detector B as well as Detector A show occupied and the problem is exposed.

One of the ways to determine where "sneak circuits" exist, is to unplug all the detectors. Then plug is one detector at a time leaving all other detectors unplugged.

Then with DCC power turned on, set your Volt-Ohm Meter(VOM) to measure AC volts and connect the red lead to the common "S" rail and use the black lead to check every N-rail location of your entire railroad to see where you have track power. The only location where you should read track voltage (12 to 14 volts AC for most meters), is in the track section corresponding the detector that is plugged in.

I the above test determines that you have voltage outside of the detected section, then you have a sneak circuit that must be located and removed.

Repeat this procedure for each detector on your layout.

Once every detected section correctly powers only that section and no other section, then you should be home free.


Bruce Chubb